STATE, LAW, AND SELF-GOVERNMENT IN THE VIEWS OF THEORETICIANS OF RUSSIAN ANARCHISM OF THE LATE XIX – EARLY XX CENTURIES


Cite item

Full Text

Abstract

The issue of self-government and its role in the state is addressed in all political theories, concepts, and doctrines starting from the extreme antiquity and is important nowadays as well. The author of this paper carries out the analysis of the views of Russian anarchism originators M.A. Bakunin and P.A. Kropotkin on the role of the state and self-governing communes that were followed by the anarcho-syndicalism representative D. Novomirsky. The paper contains the problematic-chronological analysis of the literature covering this problem. The author indicates not adequately investigated spheres concerning the study of regulators of social relations in a nonstate community of anarchists. The paper reveals the sources of the negation of state and law by the anarchism theoreticians who proved that the existence of a state was caused by the necessity of legal and powerful defense of the property. It is noted that the works of M.A. Bakunin do not demonstrate a clear image of the future arrangement of the society, but only a rough description of the uniting from top to bottom of self-governing communes. The paper reveals the development of these ideas in the works of P.A. Kropotkin who gave the detailed description of the anarchistic community and the attitude of self-governing communes to the asocial elements as to ill people who however have the right to life. The community of anarchists should not have fear to be punished. The paper considers the evolution of the ideas of nonstate arrangement under the influence of the development of industry and the growth of working class that caused the formation of such its variant as the anarcho-syndicalism. The author notes the specificity of the views of this trend in anarchism on the problem of creation of self-governing communes, writes about a new vision of the community arrangement caused by trade unions and their role in the industrial management. The exaggeration of awareness and voluntariness in observing the regulations of the interpersonal relations and attitude toward labor is highlighted. The author determines the importance of mutual agreements based on the equity as well as the arbitration court and coordinating authorities. It is specified that the main principle in the communes’ activity is the principle of non-intervention in the internal affairs of other communes.

About the authors

Irina Anatolievna Prokhorenko

Togliatti State University, Togliatti

Author for correspondence.
Email: Irina.A.Pr@mail.ru

PhD (History), assistant professor of Chair of Theory and History of State and Law

Russian Federation

References

  1. Izgoev A.S. Nashi politicheskie partii [Our political parties]. Petrograd, Sinodalnaya Tipografiya Publ., 1917. 44 p.
  2. Velikhov L. Sravnitelnaya tablitsa russkikh politicheskikh partiy. Opyt sistematizatsii sovremennykh politicheskikh napravleniy [Comparative table of Russian political parties. The experience of systematization of modern political trends]. Sankt Petersburg, Amerikanskaya knigopechatnya Publ., 1906. 1 skl. tabl.
  3. Velikhov L. Sravnitelnaya tablitsa russkikh politicheskikh partiy. Novye partii i soyuzy [Comparative table of Russian political parties. New parties and unions]. Sankt Petersburg, Sever Publ., 1906. Ch. 2, 1 skl. tabl.
  4. Gorev B.I. Anarkhisty, maksimalisty i makhaevtsy. Anarkhicheskie techeniya v pervoy russkoy revolyutsii [Anarchists, maximalists and “makhaevists”. Anarchic trends in the first Russian revolution]. Moscow, Kniga Publ., 1918. 69 p.
  5. Plekhanov G.V. Anarchism and Socialism. Sochineniya. Moscow, Gosizdat Publ., 1923. Vol. IV, pp. 1–54.
  6. Svyatlovskiy V.V. Ocherki po anarkhizmu [Essays on Anarchism]. Petrograd, Gos. izd-vo Publ., 1922. 72 p.
  7. Yaroslavskiy E. Anarkhizm v Rossii [Anarchism in Russia]. Moscow, Gospolitizdat Publ., 1939. 116 p.
  8. Komin V. Anarkhizm v Rossii [Anarchism in Russia]. Kalinin, Gos. ped. in-t Publ., 1969. 244 p.
  9. Kanev S.N. Oktyabrskaya revolyutsiya i krakh anarkhizma. Borba partii bolshevikov protiv anarkhizma. 1917–1922 gody [October revolution and the failure of anarchism. The struggle of party of bolshevists against anarchism. 1917–1922]. Moscow, Mysl’ Publ., 1974. 431 p.
  10. Kanev S.N. Revolyutsiya i anarkhizm: iz istorii borby revolyutsionnykh demokratov i bolshevikov protiv anarkhizma. 1870–1917 gody [Revolution and anarchism: excerpts on the history of the struggle of the revolutionary democrats and bolshevists against anarchism. 1870–1917]. Moscow, Mysl’ Publ., 1987. 328 p.
  11. Borisenok Yu.A., Oleynikov D.I. Mikhail Aleksandrovich Bakunin. Voprosy istorii, 1994, no. 3, pp. 55–76.
  12. Blauberg I.I. Anarchism: what do we know about it? Voprosy filosofii, 1990, no. 3, pp. 165–170.
  13. Lebedeva T.P. On the problem of the analysis of some ideas of the anarchism theoreticians. Sotsialno-politicheskie nauki, 1990, no. 8, pp. 96–105.
  14. Pirumova N. The rebellious prince. Argumenty i fakty, 1990, no. 40.
  15. Tvardovskaya V.A., Itenberg B.S. K. Marx and M.A. Bakunin: the struggle of ideas and ambitions. Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya, 1997, no. 3, pp. 58–77.
  16. Shubin A. To the anarchy through the self-organization of working people – the slogan of Russian anarchists. Nauka i zhizn’, 1991, no. 5, pp. 34–53.
  17. Bakunin M.A. Statehood and anarchy. Filosofiya. Sotsiologiya. Politika. Moscow, Pravda Publ., 1989, pp. 291–527.
  18. Kropotkin P.A. Rechi buntovshchika [Speeches of a rebel]. Sankt Petersburg, Redaktor-izdatel Valeriy Brodskiy Publ., 1906. 178 p.
  19. Kropotkin P.A. Modern science and anarchy. Khleb i volya. Sovremennaya nauka i anarkhiya. Moscow, Pravda Publ., 1990, pp. 320–642.
  20. Kropotkin P.A. Predstavitelnoe gosudarstvo [A representative state]. Moscow, Svob. Kommuna Publ., 1908. 15 p.
  21. Kropotkin P.A. Bread and Will. Khleb i volya. Sovremennaya nauka i anarkhiya. Moscow, Pravda Publ., 1990, pp. 3–319.
  22. Kropotkin P.A. Zapiski revolyutsionera [Notes of a revolutionary]. Moscow, Mysl’ Publ., 1990. 526 p.
  23. Novomirskiy D. Manifest anarkhistov-kommunistov [Manifesto of Communist anarchists]. Moscow, Moskovskaya federatsiya anarkhicheskikh grupp Publ., 1918. 33 p.
  24. Novomirskiy D. Iz programmy sindikalnogo anarkhizma [From the program of syndical anarchism]. Odessa, Golos truda Publ., 1907. 96 p.

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML

Copyright (c)



This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies